Tony's Pizza Lake Charles-inspired baked veggie po-boy filled with broccoli, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, peppers and melted cheese.
| | | | |

The Sandwich I Never Forgot: Tony’s Pizza, Lake Charles & a Taste of the 1990s

Tony’s Pizza in Lake Charles, Louisiana holds one of my favourite food memories from my university years. And the most extraordinary part? Nearly thirty years later, the restaurant is still there, and the sandwich I fell in love with is STILL on the menu!

Oh, my goodness. Sometimes life hands you the most wonderful little surprises.

Recently, while exploring New Orleans po-boy traditions for Cooking With Kimberly, I found myself remembering an absolutely unforgettable vegetarian sandwich from my years at McNeese State University in Lake Charles, Louisiana.

I remembered the restaurant as Tony’s, although it had been nearly three decades since I’d eaten one of those sandwiches. Searching for Tony’s Pizza Lake Charles brought that memory right back to me.

And then, with a little searching, there it was.

Tony’s Pizza. Still operating. Still in Lake Charles. And still serving their incredible Baked Veggie Po-Boy!

You can imagine my excitement!

But to explain why this discovery means so much to me, we need to travel back to the late 1990s, when I was a student-athlete, living in a little corner house, and occasionally treating myself to a sandwich I can practically still taste today.

My McNeese State University Years in Lake Charles

Tony's Pizza Lake Charles-inspired baked veggie po-boy filled with broccoli, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, peppers and melted cheese.
Inspired by the unforgettable Baked Veggie Po-Boy I enjoyed at Tony’s Pizza during my McNeese State University years.

From approximately 1997 to 1999, I attended McNeese State University in Lake Charles, Louisiana.

I played on the university softball team, and my boyfriend at the time, Kenney, who would later become my husband, was on the track team.

Between university classes, athletics, practices, and everything else we had going on, our days could be exhausting.

We’d come home tired, dirty, sweaty, or all three!

Of course, being university students also meant watching our money. Eating out all the time wasn’t particularly practical, and I usually cooked at home.

There was another consideration, too.

I was vegetarian at the time, but Kenney ate meat.

Consequently, dinner often meant preparing a vegetarian meal for myself and a separate dish with meat for him.

I enjoyed cooking, naturally, and I loved having friends over and cooking for everyone. Even back then, preparing good food and sharing it with people made me happy.

Living in Louisiana was especially exciting for someone who loved food as much as I did. The ingredients, regional cooking traditions, and richness of the local culture gave me so much to explore and appreciate.

Still, after a long day on the softball field and attending classes, sometimes the last thing I wanted to do was prepare two different dinners.

And that’s where Tony’s Pizza came into the picture.

Our First Date at Tony’s Pizza Lake Charles

In fact, I’m quite certain Tony’s was our very first date!

Kenney knew the way to my heart was through my stomach. LOL! Before taking me there, he made sure Tony’s had vegetarian options so there would be something I could enjoy. I remember that thoughtful little detail even now.

We may even have eaten inside the restaurant on that first occasion. What I remember more clearly from the visits that followed is ordering ahead, picking up our meals, and taking them home after a tiring day.

For someone who already adored cooking and was surrounded by Louisiana’s wonderful food culture, that Baked Veggie Po-Boy was a particularly impressive introduction.

A Sweet Little Corner House on Alamo Street

During those years, I lived in a little corner house on Alamo Street in Lake Charles.

It wasn’t a particularly large home, but I absolutely loved it. It was so cute inside!

Recently, I even managed to find the house again on a map. The little corner house was immediately familiar, although the surrounding area looks different today.

That brought back another wave of memories.

I can still picture those university days, when Kenney and I were juggling school, sports, and ordinary everyday responsibilities.

On evenings when neither of us felt like doing much more than eating and relaxing, picking up something delicious on the way home was a wonderful treat.

After what I believe was our first date there, we generally weren’t going to Tony’s to sit down for dinner.

As I remember it, we’d usually order ahead, stop to pick up our food, and bring everything back to the house.

That meant we could enjoy a great meal without spending the evening cooking and cleaning up afterward.

And believe me, some nights that was exactly what we needed!

Tony’s Pizza Lake Charles: The Sandwich I Never Forgot

Now, Tony’s wasn’t simply a pizza restaurant.

I remember looking up at their menu and seeing an incredible assortment of po-boy sandwiches.

There seemed to be so many delicious possibilities!

I particularly remember shrimp among the seafood selections. In my mind, I also associate those Louisiana years with crawfish and other fried seafood, although after so many years I wouldn’t claim to remember every sandwich Tony’s offered back then.

What I do remember is being impressed by the variety.

And as it turns out, Tony’s still has an extensive po-boy menu today.

But despite all those tempting choices, I knew exactly what I wanted.

The Baked Veggie Po-Boy.

Ohhhhh, that sandwich!

Why Tony’s Baked Veggie Po-Boy Was So Extraordinary

Close-up of a baked veggie po-boy showing fluffy French bread, broccoli, artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, mushrooms and melted cheese.
Fresh, crisp French bread, fluffy inside and packed with vegetables and melted cheese—just how I remember those wonderful po-boys!

I’m not exaggerating when I tell you that this was one of the most delicious vegetarian sandwiches I’ve ever eaten.

And I’ve eaten plenty of sandwiches!

What made it so special wasn’t one unusual ingredient or a complicated sauce.

It was how beautifully everything worked together.

That Incredible Fresh French Bread

First, there was the bread.

Fresh, wonderful French bread that became beautifully crisp on the outside when the sandwich was baked, yet remained soft and fluffy inside.

It had exactly the right balance of textures.

The exterior had a satisfying crispness, while the inside remained tender enough to enjoy without fighting your way through a tough loaf.

And somehow, that bread was sturdy enough to hold an extraordinary amount of filling!

Because let me tell you, Tony’s didn’t skimp on the vegetables.

Those little po-boys were PACKED!

The Vegetables, the Sweetness & That Melted Cheese

Inside the sandwich was a beautiful assortment of vegetables.

Broccoli, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, sun-dried tomatoes, and more.

The sun-dried tomatoes brought concentrated flavour and a lovely sweetness. The peppers and onions contributed their own sweet, savoury notes, while the mushrooms added depth.

And then there were the artichoke hearts!

I’ve always been a sucker for artichoke hearts, so naturally, I loved finding them tucked inside this wonderful sandwich.

But what really brought everything together was the melted cheese.

It was almost like a delicious, cheesy glue holding all that vegetable goodness together.

The cheese melted through the filling, giving the sandwich a lovely richness while helping all those generous ingredients stay where they belonged.

The result was indulgent, satisfying, and packed with flavour.

Honestly, even though I’m no longer vegetarian, I would order that sandwich again in a heartbeat.

And Then There Was the Broccoli!

Here’s the funniest part.

Of all the ingredients in Tony’s Baked Veggie Po-Boy, do you know which one I remember most vividly?

The broccoli!

Yes, broccoli.

After nearly thirty years, I think that may be the only sandwich I’ve ever had that contained broccoli!

At least, it’s the only one that has stayed in my memory.

And somehow, it was absolutely perfect.

The broccoli worked beautifully with the cheese, artichokes, mushrooms, peppers, and that magnificent French bread.

Everything complemented everything else.

My goodness, my mouth is watering just thinking about it!

What Did Kenney Order at Tony’s?

Chicken Alfredo with grilled chicken, creamy fettuccine pasta, Parmesan cheese and parsley, inspired by Tony's Pizza in Lake Charles.
Chicken Alfredo was the sort of hearty pasta dish Kenney loved, and one he may have ordered during our university days in Lake Charles.

While I was devoted to my veggie po-boy, Kenney usually preferred something with meat.

I seem to remember him ordering pasta quite often.

Knowing his tastes, spaghetti with meatballs or chicken Alfredo sounds exactly like something he would have chosen.

But I can’t remember which dish he ordered on any particular evening, and I won’t pretend otherwise.

Interestingly, Tony’s current menu still includes both Spaghetti with Meatballs and Chicken Alfredo.

They also serve a regular Meatball Po-Boy and a Meatball Special Po-Boy!

So there’s certainly no shortage of possibilities for someone who enjoys a hearty Italian-inspired meal.

For us, the important thing was picking up something we both wanted to eat and bringing it home after a long day.

A simple pleasure, perhaps, but those little pleasures can become some of the best memories.

The Night My Beautiful Veggie Po-Boy Hit the Floor

Of course, not every Tony’s memory is quite so glorious.

There’s one particular evening I still remember vividly.

We’d picked up our food and brought it home, and I was looking forward to eating my wonderful Baked Veggie Po-Boy.

Somehow, though, the sandwich slipped right out of my hands.

And landed on the floor!

OH, NO!

My beautiful sandwich!

I was so sad. So disappointed!

Here was this fabulous meal I’d been anticipating all day, and suddenly it was lying on the floor.

I can still remember that awful feeling.

What I can’t remember is what happened next.

Did Kenney go back to Tony’s for another one? Did we decide it was too late or too much trouble? Did I end up eating something else?

I truly don’t know.

But nearly thirty years later, I still remember dropping that sandwich!

Apparently, some food tragedies are simply unforgettable.

And if you’ve ever dropped something particularly delicious that you were really looking forward to eating, I’m sure you understand!

Rediscovering Tony’s Pizza Lake Charles Almost Thirty Years Later

Fast-forward to 2026.

While researching the Oak Street Po-Boy Festival in New Orleans and reminiscing about Louisiana sandwiches, I started wondering whether Tony’s was still around.

I remembered the name, the city, and that incredible vegetable sandwich.

But after almost three decades, I had no idea whether the restaurant would still exist.

So we looked it up.

And there it was!

Tony’s Pizza, 335 East Prien Lake Road, Lake Charles, Louisiana.

Still open!

Even more remarkably, Tony’s has been serving the Lake Charles community since 1968.

According to the restaurant’s own history, Charles Dickson founded Tony’s in its original building, which has been expanded over the years.

The restaurant also explains that many of its original recipes and menu items remain part of its identity.

That alone was a lovely discovery.

But then we checked the current menu.

And guess what?

THE BAKED VEGGIE PO-BOY IS STILL THERE!

I could hardly believe it!

The Baked Veggie Po-Boy Is Still on Tony’s Menu

One of the most exciting parts of rediscovering Tony’s was reading the description of that familiar sandwich.

A published restaurant menu describes an oven-baked vegetable po-boy featuring broccoli, artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, mushrooms, black and green olives, bell peppers, onions, cheeses, lettuce, tomato, and house Italian dressing on French po-boy bread.

There it was.

The broccoli. Those artichokes! Then the peppers and onions, mushrooms, and sun-dried tomatoes.

All those wonderful ingredients I remembered!

And the melted cheese that helped bring everything together.

Although I can’t establish whether every detail of the recipe is identical to the sandwich I ate in the late 1990s, the description is remarkably close to my memory.

Reading it was like finding a little piece of my university years waiting for me.

I also noticed ingredients I hadn’t specifically remembered, including olives, lettuce, tomato, and Tony’s house Italian dressing.

It’s quite possible those were part of the sandwiches I enjoyed, too. After all, nearly thirty years have passed!

What I know for certain is that the broccoli, artichoke hearts, peppers, onions, mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, cheese, and fresh bread made an unforgettable impression on me.

Tony’s Pizza Still Has an Impressive Po-Boy Menu

Another thing I remember about Tony’s is looking at the menu and seeing what seemed like an enormous assortment of po-boy sandwiches.

I remember thinking there were so many different kinds!

And today, the restaurant continues to offer a substantial selection.

Among its currently listed sandwiches are:

  • Baked Veggie Po-Boy
  • Shrimp Po-Boy
  • Meatball Po-Boy
  • Meatball Special Po-Boy
  • Roast Beef Po-Boy
  • Roast Beef & Cheese Po-Boy
  • Chicken Parmesan Po-Boy
  • Baked Italian Po-Boy
  • Muffaletta Po-Boy
  • Smoked Turkey Po-Boy
  • Ham & Cheese Po-Boy
  • Other meat and specialty sandwiches

The restaurant also continues serving pizzas, pasta dishes, appetizers, and other Italian-inspired favourites.

So yes, that wonderful variety I remember is still part of Tony’s identity today.

And I think it’s marvellous that their Baked Veggie Po-Boy remains among the choices.

Clearly, I’m not the only person who appreciates a great vegetable sandwich!

You can explore their current online ordering menu or visit the official Tony’s Pizza website.

Why Some Food Memories Stay With Us

I’ve been thinking about why this particular sandwich has remained so vivid in my memory.

After all, I’ve eaten an extraordinary variety of foods over the years.

I’ve cooked, experimented, travelled, explored different cuisines, and discovered countless interesting ingredients and techniques.

Yet here I am, almost thirty years later, remembering broccoli inside a baked vegetable po-boy!

I think part of the answer is that food memories are rarely about flavour alone.

They’re also about where we were in our lives.

For me, Tony’s takes me back to McNeese State University, the softball field, the little corner house on Alamo Street, and those evenings when Kenney and I were exhausted from training and classes.

It reminds me of being young, managing a university student’s budget, preparing two different dinners most nights, and occasionally enjoying the luxury of bringing something delicious home instead.

It even reminds me of the evening when my sandwich slipped through my fingers and landed on the floor!

All those details became part of the story.

And now, discovering that Tony’s is still operating—and that the Baked Veggie Po-Boy is still available—has given that old memory a wonderful new chapter.

Can We Recreate Tony’s Baked Veggie Po-Boy at Home?

Baked veggie po-boy ingredients including broccoli, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, sun-dried tomatoes, cheese and French bread.
Broccoli, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, peppers, onions, sun-dried tomatoes and cheese—the incredible combination that made Tony’s veggie po-boy unforgettable.

Oh, you can be certain that I’ve thought about it!

In fact, rediscovering the restaurant has inspired me to revisit the idea of making a Tony’s-inspired baked vegetable po-boy in my own kitchen.

But recreating a memorable sandwich requires more than simply putting the same vegetables between two pieces of bread.

The bread needs to be right.

It should become crisp on the outside while remaining tender and fluffy inside.

The vegetables should be cooked properly and retain their individual flavours without making the sandwich soggy.

The sun-dried tomatoes, peppers, and onions need to contribute that lovely sweetness I remember.

The artichoke hearts and mushrooms should bring flavour and texture, while the broccoli deserves a starring role!

And, of course, we need enough melted cheese to hold everything together.

I’d also want to explore Tony’s house Italian dressing, since it appears in the restaurant’s published sandwich description.

We may not be able to reproduce their proprietary recipe exactly, but we can certainly create a thoughtful homemade interpretation inspired by those unforgettable flavours.

That’s a delicious cooking project I look forward to exploring!

Explore More Sandwiches & Louisiana Cooking

My rediscovery of Tony’s began while exploring the history and culinary traditions of Louisiana po-boy sandwiches.

If you enjoy regional sandwiches and the stories behind them, you may also enjoy exploring our Cooking With Kimberly recipe archives and video collections.

Take a look at our Louisiana Gulf Coast recipes for more of the regional flavours that made my university years so memorable. And if you’re in the mood for seafood, explore How to Make Kimberly’s Louisiana Seafood Gumbo.

Sandwich Recipes + Reviews

Discover sandwich ideas, reviews, cooking techniques, and delicious combinations in our Sandwich Recipes + Reviews playlist.

Watch Sandwich Recipes + Reviews on YouTube.

Louisiana, Cajun & Creole Recipes + Reviews

For more Louisiana culinary inspiration, explore the flavours, ingredients, and cooking traditions represented in our Louisiana, Cajun & Creole Recipes + Reviews playlist.

Watch Louisiana, Cajun & Creole Recipes + Reviews on YouTube.

Italian Recipes + Reviews

And since Tony’s is also an Italian restaurant known for its pizza, pasta, and meatball dishes, our Italian Recipes + Reviews playlist is another wonderful place to find inspiration.

Explore Italian Recipes + Reviews on YouTube.

You can also browse our Pasta, Noodles & Grains Recipes + Reviews, Baked Pasta Recipes + Reviews, Restaurant Recipes + Reviews, and Pizza Recipes + Reviews.

Where to Find Tony’s Pizza in Lake Charles

If you’re visiting Lake Charles and would like to explore the restaurant that inspired this food memory, Tony’s Pizza is still serving customers at its longtime location.

Tony’s Pizza
335 East Prien Lake Road
Lake Charles, Louisiana 70601
Telephone: 337-477-1611

Official website: tonyspizzainc.com

Check the restaurant’s current hours, menu, and availability before visiting or placing an order, as details may change.

This article is a personal food memory, not a sponsored review or a claim that I’ve recently eaten at the restaurant.

Some Sandwiches Are Simply Unforgettable

It’s amazing how a single food can bring back so many memories.

For me, Tony’s Baked Veggie Po-Boy brings back a little corner house in Lake Charles, university softball, long days of training, Kenney’s track schedule, and the simple pleasure of picking up dinner instead of cooking two separate meals.

I remember the smell and texture of fresh French bread, the sweetness of sun-dried tomatoes and peppers, the richness of melted cheese, and those wonderful artichoke hearts.

And, of course, the broccoli!

There was also that unfortunate po-boy that somehow ended up on the floor.

But most of all, it reminds me that some of the simplest food experiences can stay with us for a lifetime.

Finding out that Tony’s Pizza is still operating in Lake Charles was wonderful enough.

Discovering that the very sandwich I loved during my university years is still on the menu?

That’s something special.

Nearly thirty years later, I would happily order that Baked Veggie Po-Boy again.

In fact, after remembering all those incredible ingredients, I’m practically craving one right now!

Here’s to Tony’s Pizza, unforgettable sandwiches, and the beautiful little food memories that follow us through life.

Until next time…

Be a Champion in Your Kitchen, and Eat Deliciously!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Posts